Welcome To First Avenue Supply House

First Avenue Supply House has proudly supplied the Metropolitan Area with plumbing, heating, and electrical material for over 20 years.

Whether you are changing a faucet or require cast iron pipes for new construction – First Avenue Supply has you covered. We carry brand names such as A.O Smith, Honeywell, Delta, Gerber, and numerous others.

If you are working in the industry, we are here at your convenience.

Our organization has been servicing the Upper East Side for 35+ years. “East 84th Plumbing and Electrical Supply” is an extension of “New York Paint & Hardware Store” at 1593 2nd ave. In 2001 we decided to open this specialty store in order to expand our Plumbing and Electrical selection.

Store Policies

Delivery Policy: Delivery is free throughout the NYC area.
A curb side delivery policy will be in effect if our vehicle cannot be legally parked. Our drivers are ready to help you unload – as long as there is no risk of parking tickets.

Account Credit Policy: If you or your company wish to open an account with us, a credit form must be filled out. 30 – 60 Day accounts are standard, and credit lines vary depending on your references and payment promptness.

Returns – No returns are allowed for electronic devices. All other material is returnable as long as the receipt is presented.

Through a standard approval procedure it is possible to set up a credit account as well as automated invoice email notifications upon your request.

Products Available

Steam Valves


Pipes and Fittings






Kitchen Plumbing

Toilet Seat

Toilet Tank Parts

Bathroom Plumbing

Radiator Valves No Hub

Pipes Cut

Faucet Repair & Replace

Shower Leak

All light Bulbs

Energy Saver




Light Fixtures

Emt Pipe Boxes

Breakers Fuses

Wire by the Foot

BX Cable


Carbon Monoxide and Smoke Detectors

Lumber Plywood Doors Moldings


Glass & Plastic sheets

Paint and Paint supplies


Radiator Covers

Building Hardware Tracks - Studs


Air Compressors



Drills & Drivers

Paint Sprayers



Tile Saws



Handheld Sanders

Demolition Hammers


Hanging TV

Locksmith service

Lamp Repairing

Handyman Services

Install Window Molded Air Conditioner

Picture Hanginng

Electrical Repairs

What We Carry



Awesome Service and for such a small store they seem to have everything I need EVERY TIME I go there! Willie is very knowledgeable and always happy to help! Great "best kept secret" in the Upper West side!


Awesome service. I needed some custom cuts on plexiglass and they took their time to do an awesome job on it at an entirely reasonable price. They definitely do their best to help you solve any home repair issues you have.


In terms of convenience and having what you need, they're it. Amazing customer service!!! They go more than the extra mile to accommodate their customers. If they don't have it they will get it but for the most part, they have what you need. Highly, highly recommend!


The guy frank is a cool dude great customer service when you walk in the store just look for a guy that looks like the logo that's him


Great store, very professional. They helped me figure out what to do with an old style plumbing system. After multiple attempts to figure it out myself and going to several Home Depot’s and hardware stores, but failing; Frank was able to identify the problem and get me the right parts immediately. Very professional without making you feel like you know nothing, even though you probably don’t because plumbing isn’t always that easy.


See more reviews on Google

3 Trusted Neighborhood Stores

New York Paint & Hardware
1593 2nd Ave.
New York, NY 10028


New York Paint – Yorkville
1668 1st Ave.
New York, NY 10128

First Avenue Supply House
1587 1st Ave.
New York, NY 10028

Contact Us